Call us on +44 (0)20 7465 4300
How should independent schools respond when online misogyny influences pupils – Rebecca Smart for The Independent Schools Magazine

How should independent schools respond when online misogyny influences pupils – Rebecca Smart for The Independent Schools Magazine

Rebecca Smart, Legal Director and Defence & Investigations expert at Payne Hicks Beach, has been featured in The Independent Schools Magazine, where she discusses the growing challenge of misogyny in schools and how educational establishments can respond effectively through safeguarding, early intervention and education.

Rebecca’s article has been reproduced below with kind permission.

Click here to read more.


Schools are increasingly facing the challenge of misogynistic attitudes among pupils, with degrading language, sexualised comments and threats becoming normalised and too often dismissed as “banter”. Addressing such behaviour effectively is essential. Doing so not only fosters a safe, respectful and inclusive learning environment, but also protects a school’s reputation and maintains parental confidence. The issue has taken on added significance following the introduction of the updated Relationships, Sex and Health Education (RSHE) curriculum in September 2026, which places a greater emphasis on tackling misogyny, challenging harmful online narratives and helping pupils understand the impact of incel culture, pornography and unhealthy attitudes towards consent and relationships.

When does behaviour cross a criminal threshold?

As a solicitor specialising in youth crime and serious sexual offences, I am regularly instructed in cases involving allegations between pupils on school premises. For independent schools, understanding when behaviour risks crossing the criminal threshold is essential. This is not only a safeguarding issue but also a matter of legal risk. Schools may face criticism where harmful behaviour is minimised or inadequately investigated, but equally where matters are escalated unnecessarily, causing disproportionate harm to a child.

The warning signs schools should not ignore

Misogynistic attitudes rarely emerge through a single serious incident. More often, they develop gradually through language, peer-group dynamics and exposure to harmful online content. Independent schools are particularly well placed to identify emerging concerns because of the close pastoral relationships that often exist between staff and pupils.

Warning signs may include the routine use of degrading or sexualised language towards girls, the ranking or objectification of female pupils, repeated references to misogynistic influencers, hostility towards discussions about consent or equality, and the normalisation of sexist jokes under the guise of humour. Schools should also be alert to coercive or controlling behaviour in teenage relationships, online harassment and the sharing of inappropriate content through social media or messaging platforms.

The key is not to view incidents in isolation. Behaviour that may initially appear immature or attention-seeking can, if left unchallenged, become embedded within a wider school culture.

Recording, escalating and investigating concerns

Designated safeguarding leads should be informed where behaviour involves sexual harassment, threats, coercion, online abuse or any indication of harm to another pupil. Consideration should then be given to whether parents should be informed, whether external agencies should be consulted and what immediate measures are required to safeguard those affected.

Schools should avoid both extremes – minimising harmful conduct on the one hand, and rushing immediately to punitive outcomes on the other. Investigations should be fair, proportionate and focused on safeguarding, while ensuring that all parties are treated appropriately.

Engaging constructively with boys influenced by online misogyny

Many independent schools are reporting concerns about boys consuming content from influencers and online communities that promote hostility towards women, rigid gender stereotypes and distorted views of relationships.

While allegations of sexual assault, physical violence or involvement with prohibited substances may be obvious, many situations are less clear cut.

Importantly, schools are not expected to act as criminal investigators. Their role is to identify when behaviour may have moved beyond a disciplinary matter and requires a safeguarding response, external consultation or referral. Seeking specialist advice at an early stage can help schools strike the right balance between protecting pupils and avoiding the unnecessary criminalisation of children.

Successful interventions tend to focus on education and critical thinking rather than confrontation.

Discussions about consent, respect, accountability and healthy masculinity are often more effective than simply condemning particular individuals or online personalities. Many pupils exposed to misogynistic content do not fully understand its implications or recognise the real-world impact of the attitudes being promoted. Early intervention is therefore crucial.

A leadership issue

For independent schools, responding to misogyny must extend beyond the RSHE curriculum. It requires a whole-school approach involving leadership, safeguarding policies, staff training, pupil education and clear behavioural expectations.

Schools that identify concerns early, record them carefully and engage pupils constructively are far better placed to protect their communities and themselves, than those that wait for a serious incident to occur. As schools implement the updated RSHE framework, they have an opportunity not only to meet their safeguarding obligations, but to foster cultures of respect, safety and accountability, benefiting every pupil.


For further information, please get in touch with Rebecca Smart. Alternatively, telephone on 020 7465 4300
Key Contact
Rebecca Smart
Rebecca Smart
Legal Director
View Profile