Call us on +44 (0)20 7465 4300
philip-chow-k-BUBDFQe1U-unsplash
30 April 2026

Brent Cross landlords sue John Lewis for slice of click-and-collect revenue – Scott Goldstein for Property Week

Property disputes expert Scott Goldstein at Payne Hicks Beach comments on the legal risk arising from the Brent Cross landlords’ claim against John Lewis, warning that judicial interpretation of historic leases could allow landlords to include click‑and‑collect receipts in turnover rent, exposing retailers to backdated claims and unexpected liabilities.

Click here to read the full article: Brent Cross landlords sue John Lewis for slice of click-and-collect revenue | Property Week

Scott’s comments have been reproduced below with kind permission.


Scott comments:

“The case will be decided based on how the judge interprets John Lewis’s lease, so the outcome of the litigation is fact-specific.

“However, that is a double-edged sword, because whatever the court decides in the John Lewis case, enterprising landlords will have their lawyers consult their leases to see whether they can include click and collect receipts when calculating turnover rent.

“Landlords may net unexpected windfalls and retailers will feel the pain having to account for contingent liabilities they never knew they had. The issue isn’t confined to a year’s receipts, because landlords can sue for up to six years’ unpaid rent.”


For further information, please contact Scott Goldstein, Partner in the Litigation, Arbitration & Dispute Resolution department, or alternatively, telephone 07904 916 241.

Key Contact
Scott Goldstein
Partner
View Profile